How to Choose the Best Bathtub for Your Bathroom: The Ultimate Buying Guide

DK Hardware

Jan 17, 2025 • 6 min read

Introduction

Choosing the best bathtub for your bathroom is no small task. Whether you're remodeling your bathroom or installing a new one, the bathtub is often the centerpiece of the space. Not only should it provide comfort and relaxation, but it should also suit your bathroom’s design, size, and functionality needs.

In this comprehensive bathtub buying guide, we will walk you through everything you need to know to choose the right tub for your specific needs. From understanding the types of bathtubs available to selecting the right material and installation options, we’ll cover all the essential details. Let’s dive in!

Why Choosing the Right Bathtub is Essential

A bathtub isn’t just a place to soak; it's an investment in your home. The best bathtubs for your bathroom offer both comfort and style while meeting practical needs, such as space, durability, and ease of maintenance.

Consider the purpose of your bathtub. Are you seeking a deep soaking tub for relaxation? Or do you need a space-saving tub that maximizes your bathroom's functionality? The right choice will improve your bathroom's overall aesthetic and enhance your daily living experience.

Measure Your Space – How Size Affects Your Bathtub Choice

Why Size Matters When Choosing a Bathtub

Before you even begin to look at bathtubs, it’s crucial to measure the available space in your bathroom. The last thing you want is to fall in love with a tub that’s too large for your space or too small for your needs.

Types of Bathtubs for Every Space:

Drop-In Tubs: These are mounted within a platform or surround, which makes them a versatile option for many bathroom layouts.
Freestanding Tubs: Ideal for spacious bathrooms with a focal design. These tubs stand alone and can be placed anywhere in the room.
Corner Tubs: Best for maximizing corners in compact spaces.
Alcove Tubs: Perfect for smaller bathrooms, these tubs fit into three walls, saving space.

Bathtub Size Guide

Measure the length, width, and depth of your available space.
Make sure to account for at least 3-4 feet of clearance around the bathtub for easy access.
Consider the doorway size—will the bathtub fit through your bathroom door?

Choose the Right Bathtub Shape & Style

Types of Bathtubs: Style Meets Function

When choosing the best bathtub for your bathroom, the shape and style of the tub will define the look of your space. Here are the most common types:

Drop-In Bathtubs: Drop-in tubs fit inside a platform, allowing you to customize the surrounding area with materials that suit your bathroom's aesthetic.
Freestanding Bathtubs: Known for their elegant look, freestanding tubs often serve as the centerpiece of modern bathrooms. Available in a variety of shapes (e.g., oval, rectangular), these tubs offer a luxurious soaking experience.
Corner Bathtubs: A great solution for small bathrooms, corner tubs make the most of underused corners, offering space-efficient bathing without compromising on style.
Alcove Bathtubs: These are the most common type of bathtub and are designed to fit into an alcove or nook. Typically, they’re combined with a shower, making them perfect for families.

Choosing the Right Style Based on Your Bathroom

Minimalist/Modern: Freestanding tubs or clean, angular designs.
Traditional: Clawfoot or cast iron bathtubs for a vintage feel.
Contemporary: A sleek, rectangular drop-in or alcove tub for a modern yet functional look.

Select the Best Material for Your Bathtub

Choosing the right material is essential for durability and comfort. Here are some common materials used in bathtub construction:

Acrylic: Lightweight, affordable, and easy to clean, acrylic bathtubs are a popular choice. They retain heat well and come in a variety of shapes and sizes.
Cast Iron: Durable and long-lasting, cast iron tubs have a classic appeal. They retain heat effectively but can be heavy and expensive.
Fiberglass: Known for being budget-friendly, fiberglass is lightweight but may not be as durable or long-lasting as acrylic or cast iron.
Stone Resin: This material offers a luxurious look and is excellent at retaining heat. It’s more expensive but ideal for high-end bathrooms.
Composite Materials: A mix of materials designed to combine strength and ease of maintenance. They are ideal for modern bathtubs that need to balance aesthetics with durability.

Choosing Based on Your Needs

Budget-Friendly: Opt for fiberglass or acrylic.
Luxury Look and Feel: Consider stone resin or cast iron for long-lasting elegance.

Evaluate Comfort Features for a Better Bathing Experience

A bathtub is more than just a place to bathe; it’s an experience. Look for features that will enhance your bathing comfort:

Deep Soaking Tubs: These tubs have higher sides, allowing you to immerse your body fully for a more relaxing experience.
Whirlpool Bathtubs: These bathtubs come with built-in jets that offer a soothing hydrotherapy experience, ideal for relaxation or muscle recovery.
Air Bath Tubs: Similar to whirlpool tubs, air baths have air jets that create a gentle bubbling effect, providing a softer, more soothing experience.
Heated Backrests and Floors: A heated backrest or floor can make a huge difference during the colder months, adding comfort and luxury to your bathing experience.

Factor in Installation and Maintenance

Bathtub Installation Tips

Choosing the best bathtub involves considering how it will be installed. Depending on your choice of tub, installation can be straightforward or require professional help.

DIY-Friendly Options: Alcove and corner tubs are generally easier to install and can be done by skilled DIY enthusiasts.
Professional Installation: Freestanding tubs, especially larger or more complex models (like whirlpool bathtubs), may require professional help due to their size and plumbing requirements.

Maintenance Considerations

Acrylic and Fiberglass: Both are easy to maintain with regular cleaning. Avoid harsh chemicals to preserve the material's finish.
Cast Iron and Stone Resin: Though durable, these materials may require special care to avoid scratching or chipping.

Set Your Budget and Evaluate Long-Term Value

Bathtub Cost: What’s Your Budget?

Your bathtub purchase should fit your budget, but it's also important to think about the long-term value of the investment. Consider the following:

Initial Cost vs. Durability: Acrylic and fiberglass tubs are more affordable but may require replacement sooner than cast iron or stone resin.
Energy and Water Efficiency: Look for bathtubs that offer features like water-saving systems or energy-efficient heating to reduce your bills over time.
Resale Value: High-quality bathtubs like stone resin or whirlpool tubs can increase your home's resale value, especially in bathrooms that are the focal point of your home.

Sustainable & Eco-Friendly Bathtubs

As sustainability becomes a growing concern, many homeowners are choosing eco-friendly bathtubs. These can include:

Water-Saving Features: Low-flow systems and water-efficient designs to minimize water consumption.
Recycled Materials: Bathtubs made from recycled or repurposed materials, such as composite or stone resin tubs.
Energy-Efficient Heating: Energy-saving systems that help reduce heating costs while maintaining comfort.

Conclusion

Selecting the best bathtub for your bathroom is an important decision that affects both the functionality and aesthetics of your space. By following this guide, you can make an informed choice based on your bathroom size, personal preferences, budget, and comfort needs. Whether you’re opting for a luxurious freestanding tub or a space-efficient alcove tub, your perfect bathtub is out there waiting to enhance your daily routine.